Male infanticide and primate monogamy

Reply to Dixson: Infanticide triggers primate monogamy.

We thank Alan Dixson (1) for his interest in our paper (2). Unfortunately, he seems to have misread it. First, contrary to Dixson’s claim, we did not conflate callitrichid “monogamy” with obligate monogamy in other primates, like gibbons and the small cebids. We note that these were conflated in Lukas and Clutton-Brock’s (3) recent report on the evolution of monogamy but not in our paper. Dixso...

Male infanticide leads to social monogamy in primates.

Although common in birds, social monogamy, or pair-living, is rare among mammals because internal gestation and lactation in mammals makes it advantageous for males to seek additional mating opportunities. A number of hypotheses have been proposed to explain the evolution of social monogamy among mammals: as a male mate-guarding strategy, because of the benefits of biparental care, or as a defe...

Reply to Lukas and Clutton-Brock: Infanticide still drives primate. monogamy.

For many years, it has been variously suggested that the evolution of monogamy in primates was due to paternal care, dispersed female ranging, or infanticide. It was therefore of little surprise to us that we should find that these traits are strongly associated with mating systems in primates (1). The crucial question, however, is whether these traits are potential drivers of, or secondary res...

Evolution of social monogamy in primates is not consistently associated with male infanticide.

Comparative analyses suggest that monogamous breeding systems evolved in mammals where feeding competition reduces range overlap between breeding females, preventing males from guarding more than one female at a time (1). In contrast, a recent analysis for primates suggests that monogamy evolved as a form of paternal care that reduces the risk of male infanticide (2). Here we reexamine the dist...

Classification Biological Sciences: Evolution Title The evolution of social monogamy in primates is not consistently associated with male infanticide